Complete Plant-Based Butter Guide
Master vegan butter alternatives for perfect baking, cooking, and spreading
Plant-based butter alternatives have revolutionized dairy-free baking and cooking, offering everything from perfectly flaky pie crusts to rich buttercream frosting. Whether you choose commercial vegan butter for convenience, coconut oil for natural baking, or heart-healthy avocado oil for cooking, this guide provides the exact ratios, techniques, and troubleshooting tips for perfect results every time.
Complete Plant-Based Butter Options
Commercial Vegan Butter (Earth Balance, Miyoko's)
Type: Store-bought
Best for: All-purpose baking, spreading, cooking
Ratio: 1:1 replacement
Melting point: Similar to dairy butter
Flavor: Rich, buttery, closest to dairy
Cost: $$$ (Premium)
Baking score: Excellent (5/5)
Pro Tips: Works exactly like dairy butter, some brands saltier than others
Coconut Oil (Solid)
Type: Natural fat
Best for: Baking cookies, pie crusts, frying
Ratio: 3/4 cup per 1 cup butter
Melting point: 76°F - use cold for baking
Flavor: Mild coconut taste (refined has less)
Cost: $$ (Moderate)
Baking score: Very Good (4/5)
Pro Tips: Chill before use, measure when solid, adds flakiness to pastries
Avocado Oil Spread
Type: Healthy fat blend
Best for: Heart-healthy baking, sautéing
Ratio: 1:1 replacement
Melting point: Room temperature soft
Flavor: Neutral, clean taste
Cost: $$$ (Premium)
Baking score: Good (4/5)
Pro Tips: High smoke point for cooking, healthier fat profile
Applesauce (Unsweetened)
Type: Fruit purée
Best for: Moist baked goods, muffins, cakes
Ratio: 1/2 cup per 1 cup butter
Melting point: Not applicable
Flavor: Very mild apple, mostly neutral
Cost: $ (Very affordable)
Baking score: Good for specific uses (3/5)
Pro Tips: Reduces calories, adds moisture, may make dense texture
Nut Butter (Almond, Cashew)
Type: Ground nuts
Best for: Cookies, energy bars, some cakes
Ratio: 3/4 cup per 1 cup butter
Melting point: Softens at room temperature
Flavor: Nutty, rich, distinct taste
Cost: $$ (Moderate to high)
Baking score: Good for specific recipes (3/5)
Pro Tips: Adds protein and flavor, works best in nut-based recipes
Olive Oil (Extra Virgin)
Type: Liquid fat
Best for: Savory cooking, some cakes, bread
Ratio: 3/4 cup per 1 cup butter
Melting point: Always liquid at room temp
Flavor: Fruity, robust (use light for baking)
Cost: $$ (Moderate)
Baking score: Fair (2/5) - better for cooking
Pro Tips: Use light olive oil for baking, excellent for sautéing
Perfect Applications & Techniques
Cookie Baking
Best choice: Vegan butter or solid coconut oil
Technique: Cream with sugar, use cold fat for crispy cookies
Temperature: Chill dough if using coconut oil
Timing: Same as dairy butter recipes
Pro tips: Coconut oil makes extra crispy cookies
Avoid: Liquid oils - cookies will spread too much
Cake Baking
Best choice: Vegan butter or applesauce blend
Technique: Room temperature for creaming, or oil method
Temperature: Follow recipe temperatures
Timing: May bake slightly faster with oil
Pro tips: Applesauce keeps cakes moist longer
Avoid: Too much applesauce - makes dense texture
Pie Crust
Best choice: Cold solid coconut oil or vegan butter
Technique: Keep very cold, work quickly
Temperature: Chill ingredients and dough
Timing: Blind bake may take 2-3 min longer
Pro tips: Coconut oil creates incredibly flaky crusts
Avoid: Warm fats - will make tough crust
Sautéing Vegetables
Best choice: Avocado oil or olive oil
Technique: Medium heat, add vegetables when shimmering
Temperature: Medium to medium-high
Timing: Similar to butter cooking
Pro tips: Higher smoke point than butter - less burning
Avoid: Coconut oil if you don't want coconut flavor
Toast & Spreading
Best choice: Commercial vegan butter
Technique: Let come to room temperature for easy spreading
Temperature: Room temperature
Timing: Immediate use
Pro tips: Some brands taste saltier - try different ones
Avoid: Coconut oil in summer - may be too soft
Buttercream Frosting
Best choice: High-quality vegan butter (Miyoko's)
Technique: Beat until light and fluffy, add powdered sugar gradually
Temperature: Room temperature butter
Timing: Beat 3-5 minutes for best texture
Pro tips: Chill frosting to firm up if needed
Avoid: Coconut oil - flavor too strong for frosting
Essential Baking Conversions
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Original: 1 cup butter
Substitute: 1 cup vegan butter OR 3/4 cup solid coconut oil
Notes: Coconut oil version will be extra crispy
Adjustment: Chill dough 30 min if using coconut oil
Vanilla Cake
Original: 1/2 cup butter
Substitute: 1/2 cup vegan butter OR 1/4 cup applesauce + 1/4 cup oil
Notes: Applesauce version will be more moist
Adjustment: Reduce baking time by 3-5 minutes with applesauce
Banana Bread
Original: 1/2 cup butter
Substitute: 1/2 cup mashed banana OR 1/4 cup applesauce
Notes: Extra banana flavor, very moist
Adjustment: May need extra 5-10 minutes baking time
Buttercream Frosting
Original: 1 cup butter
Substitute: 1 cup high-quality vegan butter (Miyoko's recommended)
Notes: Taste and texture nearly identical
Adjustment: Beat extra 1-2 minutes for best fluffiness
Flaky Pie Crust
Original: 8 tbsp cold butter
Substitute: 6 tbsp cold solid coconut oil
Notes: Creates incredibly flaky, tender crust
Adjustment: Keep everything very cold, work quickly
Garlic Bread
Original: 4 tbsp butter
Substitute: 4 tbsp vegan butter OR 3 tbsp olive oil
Notes: Olive oil adds extra flavor
Adjustment: Add extra pinch of salt with olive oil
Health & Nutrition Comparison
| Butter Type | Calories | Sat Fat | Benefits | Considerations |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Commercial Vegan Butter | 100 per tbsp | 3-4g | Fortified with vitamins, no cholesterol | Processed, some contain palm oil |
| Coconut Oil | 120 per tbsp | 12g | Natural, medium-chain triglycerides | High in saturated fat |
| Avocado Oil | 120 per tbsp | 2g | Heart-healthy monounsaturated fats, vitamin E | More expensive than other options |
| Applesauce | 25 per tbsp | 0g | Very low calorie, adds fiber and nutrients | Changes texture, not suitable for all recipes |
| Nut Butter | 95 per tbsp | 1-2g | Protein, healthy fats, vitamin E | Strong flavor, allergy concerns |
Troubleshooting Common Issues
❌ Cookies spread too much
Common cause: Fat too warm or using liquid oil
✅ Solution: Chill dough 30 minutes, use solid fats only
❌ Cakes are too dense
Common cause: Too much applesauce or wrong mixing method
✅ Solution: Don't exceed 50% applesauce replacement, cream properly
❌ Pie crust is tough
Common cause: Fat was too warm or overworked
✅ Solution: Keep ingredients cold, handle minimally, chill between steps
❌ Frosting won't hold peaks
Common cause: Vegan butter too soft or poor quality
✅ Solution: Chill frosting 20 minutes, use high-quality vegan butter
❌ Strong coconut flavor
Common cause: Using virgin coconut oil
✅ Solution: Switch to refined coconut oil for neutral flavor
❌ Baked goods taste flat
Common cause: Missing salt that butter usually provides
✅ Solution: Add pinch of salt when using unsalted substitutes
Quick Reference: Best Butter for Each Use
🍪 BAKING
- Cookies: Vegan butter or solid coconut oil
- Cakes: Vegan butter or applesauce blend
- Pie crust: Cold coconut oil or vegan butter
- Frosting: High-quality vegan butter only
🍳 COOKING
- Sautéing: Avocado oil or olive oil
- Spreading: Commercial vegan butter
- High heat: Avocado oil or coconut oil
- Low calories: Applesauce (baking only)
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the best plant-based butter for beginners?
Start with commercial vegan butter like Earth Balance or Miyoko's. They work exactly like dairy butter in recipes with no conversions needed, making them foolproof for beginners. They're perfect for baking, cooking, and spreading.
Can I substitute coconut oil 1:1 for butter in baking?
Use 3/4 cup solid coconut oil per 1 cup butter. Coconut oil is 100% fat while butter is about 80% fat and 20% water. Also keep coconut oil cold when baking for best results, especially in cookies and pie crusts.
Why do my cookies spread when I use plant-based butter?
This usually happens when the fat is too warm. Make sure vegan butter is properly chilled, or if using coconut oil, keep it solid. Some vegan butters have higher water content, so chilling the dough for 30 minutes often helps.
Is coconut oil healthier than vegan butter?
It depends on your health goals. Coconut oil is less processed but higher in saturated fat. Vegan butters are more processed but often fortified with vitamins and may have better fat profiles. For heart health, avocado oil or olive oil are better choices.
Can I use applesauce to replace all the butter in a recipe?
Replace up to 50% of butter with applesauce for best results. Going beyond this can make baked goods dense and gummy. Applesauce works best in moist cakes, muffins, and quick breads rather than cookies or pastries.
Which plant-based butter tastes most like dairy butter?
Miyoko's and Kite Hill are considered the closest to dairy butter in taste and texture. They're cultured like traditional butter and have that tangy, rich flavor. Earth Balance is also excellent and more widely available.
Can I make my own plant-based butter at home?
Yes! Basic vegan butter can be made with coconut oil, olive oil, non-dairy milk, and salt. For cultured butter, add lemon juice or apple cider vinegar. Homemade versions are more affordable but may not have the exact consistency of commercial brands.
Does plant-based butter work for high-heat cooking?
Some do better than others. Avocado oil-based spreads have high smoke points. Coconut oil handles medium-high heat well. Most vegan butters work for sautéing but may burn faster than dairy butter. For high-heat cooking, stick with oils rather than butter substitutes.
Complete Your Dairy-Free Kitchen
Master all plant-based dairy alternatives with our comprehensive guide collection