Complete Plant Milk Guide
Find the perfect plant milk for coffee, baking, drinking, and every recipe
With so many plant milk options available, choosing the right one can feel overwhelming. This comprehensive guide compares the most popular plant milks, their unique properties, and expert recommendations for every use case. Whether you're looking for the perfect coffee companion or the best baking substitute, we've got you covered.
Complete Plant Milk Comparison
Oat Milk
Protein: 3g per cup
Calories: 60-80
Taste: Creamy, slightly sweet, neutral
Best for: Coffee, lattes, cereal, drinking
Baking ratio: 1:1 replacement
Top brands: Oatly, Califia, Planet Oat
Pros:
- Froths well
- Creamiest texture
- Sustainable
Cons:
- Higher carbs
- May contain gluten
Soy Milk
Protein: 7g per cup
Calories: 80-100
Taste: Rich, slightly beany (unsweetened)
Best for: Baking, protein smoothies, cereal
Baking ratio: 1:1 replacement
Top brands: Silk, Westsoy, Edensoy
Pros:
- Highest protein
- Bakes well
- Affordable
Cons:
- Beany taste
- Soy allergen
- May curdle in coffee
Almond Milk
Protein: 1g per cup
Calories: 30-50
Taste: Light, nutty, thin consistency
Best for: Smoothies, cereal, low-calorie drinks
Baking ratio: 1:1 replacement
Top brands: Blue Diamond, Califia, Silk
Pros:
- Low calorie
- Mild flavor
- Widely available
Cons:
- Low protein
- Thin texture
- Water-intensive
Coconut Milk (Carton)
Protein: 0.5g per cup
Calories: 40-70
Taste: Mild coconut, creamy
Best for: Tropical smoothies, light desserts
Baking ratio: 1:1 replacement
Top brands: So Delicious, Thai Kitchen, Silk
Pros:
- Naturally sweet
- Good for keto
- Shelf-stable
Cons:
- Low protein
- High saturated fat
- Coconut flavor
Coconut Milk (Canned)
Protein: 5g per cup
Calories: 445-550
Taste: Rich, creamy, strong coconut
Best for: Curries, ice cream, rich desserts
Baking ratio: Cream replacement
Top brands: Thai Kitchen, Chaokoh, Native Forest
Pros:
- Very creamy
- High fat content
- Rich flavor
Cons:
- Very high calories
- Strong taste
- Separates
Pea Milk
Protein: 8g per cup
Calories: 70-80
Taste: Creamy, neutral, slightly earthy
Best for: Coffee, protein drinks, allergen-free baking
Baking ratio: 1:1 replacement
Top brands: Ripple, Bolthouse Farms, Silk
Pros:
- High protein
- Allergen-free
- Sustainable
Cons:
- More expensive
- Limited availability
- Slight aftertaste
Best Plant Milk for Every Use
Coffee & Lattes
Best choice: Oat Milk
Why: Froths beautifully, doesn't curdle, creamy mouthfeel
Alternatives: Soy milk (high protein), Pea milk (allergen-free)
Pro tip: Choose 'barista' versions for best frothing results
Cereal & Granola
Best choice: Oat Milk or Soy Milk
Why: Creamy texture, neutral taste, good nutrition
Alternatives: Almond milk (if calories are a concern)
Pro tip: Unsweetened versions work best to control sugar
Baking (Cakes, Muffins)
Best choice: Soy Milk
Why: Protein content helps structure, neutral when sweetened
Alternatives: Oat milk (for moisture), Almond milk (lighter results)
Pro tip: Use unsweetened in savory baking, sweetened in desserts
Smoothies
Best choice: Any based on preference
Why: Flavors blend well, texture adjustable
Alternatives: Coconut milk (tropical), Pea milk (protein boost)
Pro tip: Frozen fruit compensates for thinner milks
Drinking Straight
Best choice: Oat Milk
Why: Most similar to dairy milk in taste and mouthfeel
Alternatives: Soy milk (nutrition), Pea milk (protein)
Pro tip: Try different brands - taste varies significantly
Ice Cream Making
Best choice: Canned Coconut Milk
Why: High fat content creates creamy texture
Alternatives: Cashew cream, Oat cream (if available)
Pro tip: Chill can overnight, use only thick cream portion
Quick Reference Chart
| Milk Type | Best For | Protein | Calories | Key Benefit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oat Milk | Coffee, drinking | 3g | 60-80 | Creamiest texture |
| Soy Milk | Baking, protein | 7g | 80-100 | Highest protein |
| Almond Milk | Smoothies, cereal | 1g | 30-50 | Lowest calories |
| Pea Milk | Allergen-free | 8g | 70-80 | Allergy-friendly |
| Coconut (Canned) | Ice cream, curries | 5g | 445-550 | Richest, creamiest |
Frequently Asked Questions
Which plant milk tastes most like regular milk?
Oat milk is consistently rated as the closest to dairy milk in taste and mouthfeel. It's naturally creamy with a mild, slightly sweet flavor that doesn't overpower other ingredients. Pea milk is also very close, especially in coffee drinks.
Can I substitute plant milk 1:1 in recipes?
Yes, in most recipes you can substitute plant milk 1:1 for dairy milk. However, choose the right type: soy milk for baking (protein helps structure), oat milk for creamy dishes, almond milk for lighter applications. Canned coconut milk replaces heavy cream, not regular milk.
Why does my plant milk curdle in coffee?
Curdling happens due to acidity and heat. Soy milk is most prone to this. To prevent: choose 'barista' blends, add milk to cup first then coffee, ensure coffee isn't too hot (under 140°F), or use oat/pea milk which are more stable in acidic conditions.
Which plant milk has the most protein?
Pea milk has the highest protein (8g per cup), followed by soy milk (7g per cup). These are comparable to dairy milk (8g per cup). Oat milk has moderate protein (3g), while almond and coconut milk are lowest (0.5-1g per cup).
Are homemade plant milks better than store-bought?
Homemade plant milks are fresher, more affordable, and you control ingredients. However, store-bought versions are fortified with vitamins (especially B12, calcium, vitamin D) that homemade lacks. For nutrition, choose fortified store-bought; for taste and cost, homemade can be superior.
How long does opened plant milk last?
Most opened plant milks last 7-10 days refrigerated. Shelf-stable versions last according to expiration date before opening. Signs of spoilage: sour smell, chunky texture, or separation that doesn't mix when shaken. Always check dates and smell before using.
Can I froth plant milk for lattes?
Yes! Oat milk froths best due to protein and fat content. Look for 'barista' versions specifically designed for frothing. Soy milk also froths well. Almond milk froths but doesn't hold as long. Use cold milk and don't overheat - aim for 140-150°F maximum temperature.
Are plant milks healthier than dairy milk?
Plant milks are naturally lactose-free and often lower in calories and saturated fat. Many are fortified with vitamins and minerals. However, they may be lower in protein (except soy/pea milk) and some contain added sugars or thickeners. Choose unsweetened, fortified versions for healthiest option.
Explore More Plant-Based Dairy
Master all dairy-free alternatives with our comprehensive guides